STUDIO ETH Zürich
Spring 2022

Soil as Public Good: Restorative Commoning in the Fertile Valleys of GlattalEce Emanetoglu and Nadia Nika

Humans have sown, harvested, used, extracted, replaced, surveyed, fertilized, polluted, consumed and oppressed the soil throughout existence. This scarce matter that holds the whole life of the Earth in its pores is containing undiscovered relationships of the life cycles on every scale.

Meanwhile, the soil is a quilt covering the land to be commodified and distributed for profit—added value. Even though we are more aware of the scarcity of soil today, compared to water and forest protection, protective measurements are lagging. This reveals the value assessed to the soil in Switzerland.

However, from the regenerative viewpoint, every soil is valuable enough to be maintained and healed. On the other hand, land management conduces toward the perception of the soil as private property. Is there a way to shift the mindset of soil from being a layer on top of private property to being perceived as a 50 cm deep quilt of public good?

“Imagine a fertile Mollisol endowed with 2,200 tonnes of topsoil per hectare that is losing soil at the world’s average erosion rate of 13.5 tonnes each year and producing it at one-fortieth of that pace. Crop productivity would be affected within decades, and the topsoil—the fertile O and A horizons—would run out in about two hundred years. If erosion accelerated to 55 tonnes per hectare annually, the land would be devoid of topsoil in forty years. At 220 tonnes per hectare, this Mollisol would go extinct within a decade.” : Jo Handelsman. A World Without Soil: The Past, Present, and Precarious Future of the Earth Beneath Our Feet. 2021.

Acknowledgements

The rights of the images belong to the authors if not specified in the captions.

We would like to thank all the MAS Territorial and Urban Design teaching staff; Milica Topalović, Vesna Jovanović, Nazlı Tümerdem, Muriz Djurdjevic, Nancy Couling and Nitin Bathla, for their time and support throughout the research.

The project texts were developed within the course „Critical Writing“, SS 2022, Dr Nitin Bathla & Dr. Nancy Couling.

Thanks to; Teresa Gali-Izard, Bonnie Kate Walker, Stefan Breit, Christoph Kueffer, Jeannine van Puijenbroek, Samuel Bähler, Matthias Hollenstein, Petrissa Eckle, Christian Dunki, Sammy Leuman, Paul Rusen, Ian Rothwell, Johanna Rüegg, Felix Herzog, Andreas Kleiner, Sebastian Kussmann, Tina Siegenthaler, Florian Walder.

Sources

  • Bellacasa, Maria Puig De La. Matters of Care: Speculative Ethics in More Than Human Worlds. PostHumanities (Paperback), 2017.
  • Frichot, Hélène. Dirty Theory: Troubling Architecture. Spurbuchverlag, 2019.
  • Haller, Tobias, Karina Liechti, Martin Stuber, François-Xavier Viallon, and Rahel Wunderli. Balancing the Commons in Switzerland: Institutional Transformations and Sustainable Innovations. Routledge, 2021.
  • Häberli, Rudolf. Bodenkultur: Vorschläge Für Eine Haushälterische Nutzung Des Bodens in Der Schweiz ; Schlussbericht Des Nationalen Forschungsprogrammes (NFP) 22 “Nutzung Des Bodens in Der Schweiz.” vdf Hochschulverlag AG, 1992.
  • Keller A., Franzen J., Knüsel P., Papritz A., Zürrer M. (2018): Bodeninformations-Plattform Schweiz (BIP-CH). Thematische Synthese TS4 des Nationalen Forschungsprogramms, Nachhaltige Nutzung der Ressource Boden, (nfp 68), Bern.
  • Merriam-Webster.com Dictionary, s.v. “soil,” accessed June 11, 2022, https://www.merriam-webster.com/dictionary/soil.
  • Monbiot, George. “The Secret World beneath Our Feet Is Mind-Blowing – and the Key to Our Planet’s Future.” The Guardian, May 7, 2022. https://www.theguardian.com/environment/2022/may/07/secret-world-beneath-our-feet-mind-blowing-key-to-planets-future.
  • Montgomery, David R. Dirt: The Erosion of Civilizations. Univ of California Press, 2012.
  • Ostrom, Elinor. Governing the Commons. Cambridge University Press, 2015.
  • Pentecost, Claire. Claire Pentecost: Notizen Aus Dem Untergrund(DOCUMENTA (13): 100 Notes - 100 Thoughts, 100 Notizen - 100 Gedanken # 061). Hatje Cantz Verlag, 2012.
  • “Soil as a Resource.” In Portrait of the National Research Programme, NRP 68. Berne: Swiss National Science Foundation, 2018.
  • Zimmermann, R.C. . “The Common-Property Forests of Canton Ticino, Southern Switzerland: Relations between a Traditional Institution and the Modern State 1803-2003.” Indiana Uni, 1994.

All images are taken by Ece Emanetoglu & Nadia Nika unless mentioned otherwise.

ETH Zürich D-ARCH

Programme Director
Milica Topalović, Assoc. Professor
Chair of Architecture and Territorial Planinng

Programme Co-ordinator
Dr. Nancy Couling

EPFL ENAC

Programme Director
Paola Viganò, Professor
Habitat Research Center

Programme Co-ordinator
Dr. Tommaso Pietropolli